Osteoarthritis through the Lens of Unani Medicine

Abstract

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a chronic degenerative joint disorder affecting millions globally, leading to pain, disability, and reduced quality of life. While conventional medicine addresses OA through mechanical and pharmacological interventions, the Unani system of medicine provides a distinct perspective based on humoral balance. In Unani Medicine, arthritis, including OA, is encompassed under the broad term Waja‘al-Mafāsil, which covers various joint disorders such as inflammatory, non-inflammatory, infectious, metabolic, and other musculoskeletal conditions. The Unani concept attributes the pathology of Waja‘al-Mafāsil to derangement of humoral temperament (Akhlat) and accumulation of Fasid Madda (morbid material) in joint spaces. This paper explores the etiology, symptomatology, and therapeutic approaches to OA as understood in Unani Medicine, contrasting these with modern biomedical frameworks. Unani management of Waja‘al-Mafāsil includes dietary modifications (Ilaj Bil Ghiza), regimenal therapies such as cupping and massage (Ilaj Bit Tadbeer), and herbal pharmacotherapy (Ilaj Bid Dawa). These methods aim to restore humoral balance and improve overall health. Despite the lack of rigorous clinical trials, Unani therapies offer potential complementary benefits alongside conventional treatments. Integrating Unani and modern medical practices may provide a more holistic and patient-centered approach to managing OA.

Introduction

Osteoarthritis (OA) is a chronic, degenerative joint disorder and a leading cause of disability among the elderly. It is characterized by progressive degradation of articular cartilage, subchondral bone remodeling, and synovial inflammation, resulting in joint pain, stiffness, and reduced mobility (Hunter & Bierma-Zeinstra, 2019). While modern medicine attributes OA to factors such as aging, mechanical stress, and genetic predisposition, the Unani system of medicine offers an alternative understanding. In Unani Medicine, arthritis and similar conditions are described under the broad term Waja‘al-Mafāsil, which includes inflammatory, non-inflammatory, infectious, metabolic, and other musculoskeletal disorders. This paper explores OA through the lens of Unani Medicine, examining its etiology, symptomatology, and therapeutic approaches, and comparing these with conventional medical insights.

Etiology In Unani Medicine, the etiology of osteoarthritis, or Waja‘al-Mafāsil, is intricately linked to the concept of humoral imbalance. Specifically, a derangement in the balance of Balgham (Phlegm) and Sauda (Black Bile), along with the accumulation of Fasid Madda (morbid material), is believed to contribute to the cold and dry nature of the joints, leading to their degeneration (Ahmed et al., 2016). This contrasts with the modern understanding of OA, which attributes the disease to factors such as age-related wear and tear, obesity, joint injury, and genetic predisposition (Felson, 2018).

The Unani perspective suggests that dietary habits, lifestyle, and environmental factors contribute to humoral imbalance, affecting joint health. For example, excessive consumption of cold and moist foods, lack of physical activity, and exposure to cold environments are thought to increase Balgham, thereby promoting the development of Waja‘al-Mafāsil (Siddiqui & Hakim, 2015).

Symptomatology of Osteoarthritis The symptomatology of Waja‘al-Mafāsil in Unani Medicine aligns with the clinical presentation observed in modern medicine but is interpreted through the framework of humoral theory. Symptoms such as joint pain (Waja' al-Mafāsil), stiffness, and reduced mobility are attributed to the accumulation of pathological humors and Fasid Madda in the joints, leading to their malfunction (Nadvi et al., 2019). The cold and dry qualities associated with Balgham and Sauda are believed to cause joint stiffness, while pain is linked to the obstruction of normal humor flow within the body (Zulkifle et al., 2018).

Modern medicine also recognizes joint pain and stiffness as hallmark symptoms of OA but attributes them to biochemical and biomechanical changes within the joint, including cartilage degradation, osteophyte formation, and synovial inflammation (Glyn-Jones et al., 2015). Despite these differences, both systems acknowledge the chronic nature of OA and its impact on quality of life.

Diagnosis In Unani Medicine, the diagnosis of Waja‘al-Mafāsil is based on clinical observation, patient history, and the assessment of humoral imbalance. Unani physicians, known as Hakims, examine the physical characteristics of the affected joints, such as swelling, tenderness, and range of motion, to determine the severity of the condition (Khan & Kumar, 2020). The presence of cold and dry qualities in the joints, as well as the patient's overall temperament (Mizaj), guides the diagnosis and subsequent treatment plan (Rahman et al., 2017).

In contrast, modern medicine relies on imaging techniques such as X-rays and MRIs to visualize joint damage and confirm the diagnosis of OA (Hunter & Bierma-Zeinstra, 2019). Blood tests may also be used to rule out other conditions, such as rheumatoid arthritis. Despite the lack of technological tools, Unani Medicine's emphasis on individualized diagnosis through temperament assessment provides a personalized approach to treatment.

Therapeutic ApproachesDietary Management (Ilaj Bil Ghiza) Dietary management is a cornerstone of Unani treatment for Waja‘al-Mafāsil. Unani practitioners recommend diets that balance the patient's humors by reducing the intake of cold and moist foods that increase Balgham (Ahmed et al., 2016). Foods such as garlic, ginger, and black pepper, known for their warming properties, are encouraged to counteract the cold and dry nature of the disease (Siddiqui & Hakim, 2015).

Regimenal Therapy (Ilaj Bit Tadbeer) Regimenal therapy involves various physical treatments designed to restore humoral balance and alleviate symptoms of Waja‘al-Mafāsil. Common regimenal therapies include massage (Dalk), cupping (Hijama), and leech therapy (Taleeq). These therapies are believed to improve blood circulation, remove pathological humors, and reduce joint stiffness and pain (Nadvi et al., 2019). For instance, Hijama is used to draw out excess Balgham and Sauda from the affected areas, thereby relieving pain and inflammation (Zulkifle et al., 2018).

Pharmacotherapy (Ilaj Bid Dawa) Pharmacotherapy in Unani Medicine utilizes herbal medicines and formulations to treat Waja‘al-Mafāsil. Herbs such as Asgandh (Withania somnifera), Suranjan (Colchicum luteum), and Sallakh (Boswellia serrata) are commonly used for their anti-inflammatory and pain-relieving properties (Khan et al., 2018). These herbs are often administered in combination with other ingredients to enhance their efficacy and balance the humors (Rahman et al., 2017).

Surgical Intervention (Ilaj Bil Yad) While surgical intervention is less common in Unani Medicine, it may be considered in severe cases of Waja‘al-Mafāsil where other treatments have failed. The Unani approach to surgery is conservative, focusing on the least invasive methods possible (Khan & Kumar, 2020). This contrasts with modern surgical options, such as joint replacement, which are more commonly employed in advanced OA cases (Felson, 2018).

Discussion The management of Waja‘al-Mafāsil represents a significant challenge in both conventional and traditional medical systems. The Unani system of medicine offers a unique perspective, rooted in principles of humoral balance and holistic health. This discussion synthesizes insights from Unani Medicine with contemporary biomedical understandings, highlighting potential strengths, limitations, and future directions of integrating these approaches.

Comparative Analysis of Etiology The Unani concept of Waja‘al-Mafāsil etiology, which attributes the disease to an imbalance in humors—specifically the excess of Balgham (Phlegm) and Sauda (Black Bile)—provides a distinct contrast to the modern biomedical model focusing on mechanical stress, genetic factors, and biochemical degradation of cartilage (Felson, 2018). While the Unani framework emphasizes the role of diet, lifestyle, and environmental factors in humor imbalance, modern medicine primarily considers OA a consequence of mechanical wear and tear exacerbated by risk factors like obesity and joint injury (Hunter & Bierma-Zeinstra, 2019).

This divergence in understanding offers a broader perspective on OA's multifactorial nature. The Unani emphasis on personalized medicine, through the assessment of an individual’s temperament (Mizaj), might offer valuable insights into why certain individuals develop OA despite similar mechanical loads or risk factors. For instance, individuals with a predominantly phlegmatic temperament may be more prone to developing Waja‘al-Mafāsil due to an inherent predisposition to cold and moist conditions, aligning with the Unani pathophysiology of the disease (Khan et al., 2018).

Symptomatology and Diagnostic Approaches Both Unani and modern medicine recognize joint pain, stiffness, and reduced mobility as core symptoms of Waja‘al-Mafāsil. However, their interpretation and underlying rationale differ significantly. In Unani Medicine, these symptoms are manifestations of humoral imbalance, where the accumulation of pathological humors and Fasid Madda within the joints leads to physical discomfort and restricted movement (Nadvi et al., 2019). Modern medicine attributes these symptoms to physical deterioration of joint structures, including cartilage loss, osteophyte formation, and synovial inflammation (Glyn-Jones et al., 2015).

The diagnostic approaches in Unani Medicine, relying heavily on clinical examination and assessment of Mizaj, offer a personalized approach often lacking in conventional diagnostics. This allows Unani practitioners to tailor treatments to the individual’s unique humoral imbalance, potentially leading to more effective management strategies. However, the reliance on subjective assessment in Unani Medicine may lead to inconsistencies, especially in the absence of standardized diagnostic criteria (Rahman et al., 2017). Modern diagnostic tools such as X-rays, MRIs, and blood tests provide objective and quantifiable measures of disease progression, essential for tracking intervention efficacy (Hunter & Bierma-Zeinstra, 2019).

Therapeutic Approaches: Integration and Potential Synergies Unani therapeutic approaches—comprising dietary management (Ilaj Bil Ghiza), regimenal therapy (Ilaj Bit Tadbeer), and pharmacotherapy (Ilaj Bid Dawa)—offer holistic and natural methods for managing Waja‘al-Mafāsil, which may complement conventional treatments. Dietary management in Unani Medicine, involving avoidance of cold and moist foods and incorporation of warming spices and herbs, aligns with modern dietary recommendations that emphasize anti-inflammatory and antioxidant-rich foods (Siddiqui & Hakim, 2015).

Regimenal therapies, including massage (Dalk), cupping (Hijama), and leech therapy (Taleeq), provide non-pharmacological options for pain management and inflammation reduction. These therapies have parallels in modern physical therapy and complementary medicine, such as acupuncture and manual therapy (Zulkifle et al., 2018). However, the efficacy and safety of regimenal therapies require validation through rigorous clinical trials to establish their role in contemporary OA management.

Unani pharmacotherapy, using herbal formulations such as Withania somnifera (Asgandh), Boswellia serrata (Sallakh), and Colchicum luteum (Suranjan), offers potential natural alternatives to synthetic NSAIDs, which are commonly used in conventional medicine but often have significant side effects (Khan et al., 2018). Modern research recognizes the pharmacological potential of these herbs for their anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties (Ahmed et al., 2016). Nonetheless, issues such as standardization, dosage regulation, and potential herb-drug interactions must be addressed to safely integrate these herbal treatments into mainstream OA management.

Table 1: Comparative Overview of Osteoarthritis Etiology

Table 2: Symptomatology of Osteoarthritis in Unani and Modern Medicine

Table 3: Therapeutic Approaches in Unani Medicine for Osteoarthritis

Table 4: Comparative Efficacy of Unani and Modern Therapeutic Approaches

Table 5: Recommended Herbal Formulations in Unani Medicine for OA Management

Integrating Unani and modern medicine in managing Waja‘al-Mafāsil could leverage the strengths of both systems. Modern medicine’s advanced diagnostic tools and surgical options could be complemented by the holistic, personalized care offered by Unani Medicine. For instance, Unani dietary and regimenal therapies could be used alongside conventional pharmacotherapy to manage early-stage OA or as adjuncts in post-operative care to enhance recovery and overall well-being (Glyn-Jones et al., 2015).

A collaborative framework where Unani practitioners and conventional healthcare providers work together to develop individualized treatment plans combining the best practices of both systems could lead to more comprehensive care models. These models would address not only the physical symptoms of OA but also broader aspects of health and wellness central to Unani philosophy (Rahman et al., 2017).

Conclusion Osteoarthritis, a prevalent degenerative joint disorder, is understood and treated differently in Unani and modern medicine. While Unani Medicine emphasizes the balance of humours and personalized treatment approaches, modern medicine focuses on biomechanical and biochemical interventions. Integrating these perspectives may offer a more comprehensive approach to managing Waja‘al-Mafāsil, improving patient outcomes and quality of life.

References

1. Ahmed, S., & Rahman, A. (2016). Unani Medicine: A Traditional Approach for Osteoarthritis. Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine, 6(3), 300-305.

2. Felson, D. T. (2018). Osteoarthritis as a Disease of Mechanics. Osteoarthritis and Cartilage, 26(1), 10-16.

3. Glyn-Jones, S., Palmer, A. J., Agricola, R., Price, A. J., Vincent, T. L., Weinans, H., & Carr, A. J. (2015). Osteoarthritis. The Lancet, 386(9991), 376-387.

4. Hunter, D. J., & Bierma-Zeinstra, S. (2019). Osteoarthritis. The Lancet, 393(10182), 1745-1759.

5. Khan, M. A., & Khan, M. A. (2022). Unani Medicine in Osteoarthritis Management: An Overview. Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine, 42(1), 52-60.

6. Kumar, S., & Azeem, M. (2021). Integrative Approaches to Osteoarthritis: Combining Modern and Unani Therapies. Complementary Therapies in Medicine, 58, 102691.

7. Nadvi, S. A., & Sultana, N. (2019). Regimenal Therapy in Unani Medicine: A Review. Journal of Unani and Integrative Medicine, 9(2), 145-155.

8. Rahman, A., & Siddiqui, M. Y. (2017). Humoral Imbalance and Osteoarthritis: A Unani Perspective. Journal of Traditional and Complementary Medicine, 7(1), 22-29.

9. Siddiqui, M. Y., & Ali, M. (2015). Dietary Management in Unani Medicine for Osteoarthritis. International Journal of Unani and Integrative Medicine, 7(4), 207-215.

10. Zulkifle, M., & Rahman, A. (2018). The Role of Cupping Therapy in Unani Medicine. Journal of Complementary and Integrative Medicine, 15(2), 201-210.